We may earn revenue from the products available on this page and participate in affiliate programs.

Attention, Trader Joe’s obsessives: The grocer just released its 11th annual Customer Choice Awards, a yearly roundup of the brand’s most popular products, and the list includes more than a few cult favorites. Do you have your reusable tote bags ready?

Everything But the Bagel Seasoning took home the most-beloved overall prize—usurping last year’s Mandarin Orange Chicken—and we can totally see why. The spice is an allover fave, with food bloggers and TJ’s superfans alike professing their love for it; plus, it’s incredibly versatile. You haven’t lived till you’ve sprinkled it on your hummus

Other winners include the newish Cauliflower Gnocchi (psst: Hannah Bronfman always keeps a bag in her freezer) and Unexpected Cheddar. Check out the full list to see if your go-to made the cut. 

Aside from our edible faves, there’s one best-seller that stood out to us: the scented candles. From Honeycrisp apple to peony blossom, they’re a reminder not to sleep on Trader Joe’s home section. After all, it’s where you’ll find the perfect hostess gift, an olive wood cutting board, which pairs perfectly with—what else?—Unexpected Cheddar.

See more Trader Joe’s product recommendations: I Use These Trader Joe’s Sauces on Literally Everything Will This Trader Joe’s Spice Be the New Everything But the Bagel Seasoning? A Trader Joe’s Superfan Dishes on Her All-Time Favorite Finds