We may earn revenue from the products available on this page and participate in affiliate programs.
When I moved from my house in the Maine countryside to an apartment in Rockport, there were a thousand little adjustments. I traded a quarter-mile walk down a dirt road to check my mailbox for a key to a nearby P.O. box. Instead of driving 20 minutes to the nearest store, I could walk around the corner for a cup of coffee and a cardamom bun. And rather than hauling my trash and recycling to the end of the road each week, I suddenly had to make regular trips to the local transfer station with every recyclable sorted by material.
My new home came outfitted with a small plastic trash bin and a matching container tucked neatly inside one end of the kitchen island. I appreciated how discreet they were, but once warmer weather arrived, the pair began to emit a subtle stink. And because I preferred to stretch my transfer station visits beyond once a week, I developed an unfortunate habit: an ever-growing pile of cardboard boxes, empty Spindrift cans, cat food tins, and plastic clamshells waiting for their eventual trip out of the house. I hated looking at it, but I hadn’t found an attractive alternative. Then, Caraway launched its Trash and Recycling Duo.
Caraway Trash and Recycling Duo
As soon as I caught wind of the sleek stainless steel bins in an array of colors, I was intrigued. Plenty of trash systems are designed well to deal with waste, but these felt like they had actually been made for people who recycle frequently. The designated bin isn’t just one large container—it has two removable drawers with sturdy handles, making it easy to separate materials and carry them wherever they need to go. I was curious whether they could finally eliminate the mountain that had slowly taken over my kitchen.
First Impressions
I opted for the slim version of the products. Living alone with one cat, I knew I didn’t need the larger version, and I appreciated that the narrow profile could fit neatly along a wall or at the end of my island without monopolizing valuable floor space.
Honestly, the hardest part of the setup was choosing a color. The collection comes in cream, emerald, clay, midnight, and stone, and each one is considerably more attractive than the average receptacle. The second hardest part was breaking down the large shipping boxes after everything arrived.
Once assembled, the bins immediately looked like they belonged on display in my kitchen rather than something I was trying to hide. I landed on the emerald finish, which plays beautifully with the dark blue cabinets in my light-filled place. As the sun moves through the room, the color shifts, too, and there are moments when they almost disappear against the millwork. It’s exactly what I want from an utilitarian piece: something that earns its place without demanding attention.
The Details That Actually Matter
The biggest surprise wasn’t how they looked, but how many small details made everyday use easier. The trash bin works with standard 13-gallon bags, so there’s no need to purchase proprietary liners. The foot pedal feels sturdy, and the lid stays open while changing the bag, which is a surprisingly helpful feature I didn’t realize I’d appreciate until I stopped trying to wrestle with a falling top.
The coated stainless steel exterior has also held up remarkably well. Even after months of use, it hasn’t become covered in fingerprints the way many stainless steel finishes do.
The recycling drawers have become the real standout for me. Instead of tossing everything into one large container, I can separate materials as I go, and when it’s finally time to head to the transfer station, I simply lift out the handled drawers and carry them to my car. The quick-access hatch also makes it easy to drop in cans or paper without opening the entire bin every time.
Just as importantly, the closed design has dramatically reduced odors, most noticeably during the warmer months.
Is It Worth It?
I never expected to have strong opinions about a trash can, but this has quickly and subtly become one of my favorite upgrades to my apartment. The various design decisions add up, and the embarrassing amount of recyclables that used to accumulate in the kitchen corner has completely disappeared. The Caraway pieces are undeniably an investment, especially compared to a basic plastic bin. But if you care about keeping things tidy, regularly sort your recycling, or simply want ordinary items to feel as thoughtfully designed as the rest of your home, it’s money well spent.
Sometimes the best home upgrades aren’t the flashy ones—they’re the products that solve the minor annoyances you deal with on a daily basis. For me, that’s exactly what this Caraway duo has done.
