Inside a Soulful NYC Home With a Knockout Art Collection

In this Manhattan apartment, a monochromatic palette sets the ultimate canvas.
Black and White Living room
“There’s a personality to each object, with a point of view,” says Santana. | Alanda Table by Paolo Piva for B&B Italia, 1stdibs, $2,775; Pair of Sculptural Torch Cut Lamps by Harry Balmer, 1stdibs, $4,000. Art: Ron Gorchov.

We may earn revenue from the products available on this page and participate in affiliate programs.

For many, the West Village is a prime spot for people-watching. But for lifelong New Yorker and production designer Maria Santana, who studied at nearby Parsons School of Design, the neighborhood has a more personal allure: “It’s where I lived as a young single woman, and I’ve always loved it.”

chair in entryway

In 2002, when she spotted a newspaper ad for a one-bedroom apartment in the Butterfield House, a modernist doorman building on West 12th Street, Santana knew that she and her partner, photographer David Prince, had found their next home. “It just felt like such a lucky score,” she says.

The couple’s serendipity may come from an expertly trained eye—which both have honed for more than two decades in their creative professions. As a production designer of print campaigns for the likes of Kate Spade and Stuart Weitzman, Santana whips up entire worlds from scratch to bring a designer’s vision to life. Her field trips to flea markets, antiques shops, and galleries have settled into the home in the form of vintage curios, rare treasures, and standout art.

library with art and table

For Prince, who counts luxury brands such as Tiffany & Co. and Ralph Lauren Home as clients, photographing these items—a porcelain cup embossed with sailboats or a bronze horse figurine—is a way to examine them anew. “I buy things to take pictures more than anything,” he says, “and with the intention of looking at them differently.”

tv room with art collection

Their soulful apartment, which overlooks a landscaped garden on the ground floor, reflects a life spent collecting and cherishing beautiful objects. Although the pieces cover a spectrum of styles and eras—the New York School, minimalism, Abstract Expressionism, and 1970s interior design—they are unified by an almost exclusively black-and-white palette.

glass lobby of building

“I find neutrals very calming,” explains Santana, who also gravitates toward natural textures. The zen-like restraint of keeping to monochromes prevents the home from looking too cluttered or becoming overstimulating, while still allowing Santana and Prince to layer in new additions.

bedroom with artwork

A recent renovation in 2014 enabled them to integrate their prized pieces even more seamlessly. “I wanted to figure out how to make everything work and create a very precise space for the art,” Santana explains.

bedroom with artwork and clothes

In the airy living room, a shield-shaped painting by New York artist Ron Gorchov takes pride of place above a low-slung USM console, where a smattering of Prince’s flea market pottery finds, a black Elsa Peretti bowl, and Homage to the Square by Josef Albers create a thoughtful vignette. The minimalist color scheme of the Gorchov resonated with a young Santana, who long admired it at an antiques mall she used to frequent on West 25th Street.

“It was the first real piece of art I ever purchased,” she says proudly, though she wasn’t aware of Gorchov’s significance at the time. (Her love of spare palettes may have started there, though Santana credits Ward Bennett’s studio apartment at the Dakota—a haven of earthy beige tones and wide-open spaces—as well as the work of Sol LeWitt with informing her decorating choices.)

dining room with floor tiles

The recently remodeled kitchen boasts works on paper by Robert Motherwell, Fernand Léger, and Louise Nevelson. At the dining table, beneath a black Serge Mouille chandelier, a cluster of woven chairs by George Nakashima surrounds a collection of decorative Venini and Holmegaard glass vases, each catching the pale spring light that streams in through the windows.

cocktail glasses

The residence itself is a reflection of the landscape: In 1963, a year after the building was completed, the architecture firm of Mayer, Whittlesey & Glass received an award from the Municipal Art Society of New York for seamlessly integrating the structure into the surroundings by using bay windows and a special brown brick resembling the neighboring historic brownstones. Over the years, it has drawn its share of creatives, such as the late poet Stanley Kurtz, who were lured by the architecture and proximity to bohemian Greenwich Village.

“I like things that, if you love them, are going to last and age,” says Santana of the couple’s well-patinaed collections—and, perhaps, of the storied building they call home.

Shopping Secrets of a Production Designer

Though she leaves her computer less often to shop for props these days, Santana still enjoys the thrill of the hunt. However, she and Prince never set out with something specific in mind. “There’s an element of magic to finding things,” says Santana.

chair in corner with light

Here are their favorite haunts:


Alameda Point Antiques Faire, Alameda, California. This vintage bonanza in NorCal features more than 800 booths.


Roland Auctions, New York. Come for the estate sales, stay for the Americana oddities.


Showplace Antique & Design Center, New York. Spend the day getting lost in this Chelsea antiques mall.


City Opera Thrift Shop, New York. Browse funky finds while supporting the New York City Opera.


Elephant’s Trunk Country Flea Market, New Milford, Connecticut. Set your alarm for this festive flea—early birds often score the best deals.


Antiekcentrum, Amsterdam. Take in the stylish bric-a-brac from more than 55 dealers at this Dutch antiques market.

This story originally appeared in the spring 2018 issue with the headline “A Clean Slate.”

See more inspiring spaces from our latest issue:

The Outdoor Voices Founder’s Home Is as Cool as Her Clothing LinePatterns Rule in this Colorful Austin BungalowA Wildly Colorful Ranch That’ll Make You Want to Visit Texas ASAP

For more stories like this, sign up here for your daily dose of Domino.